Best Cigar Shops in New York City for Collectors
1.
Casa de Montecristo (Manhattan, 2nd Avenue)
Casa de Montecristo's Manhattan lounge is a premier destination for cigar collectors. With a large, climate-controlled humidor, a wide spectrum of premium brands (Montecristo, Padron, Davidoff, Cohiba, Arturo Fuente, and boutique lines), and expert staff who can guide you through limited editions, this shop bridges retail and lounge perfectly. The lounge includes TVs, comfortable seating, and strong ventilation systems so you can sample cigars right there in comfort.
2.
Martinez Handmade Cigars (Midtown / Manhattan)
Martinez Handmade Cigars is a longtime favorite among aficionados, especially for those who appreciate artistry and tradition. They roll cigars on-site, offer custom banding (so you can put your own branding or commemorations on boxes), and stock a range of in-house blends like the "NYC Blend" and Anniversary editions. For collectors who value provenance and adaptability in their collection, Martinez offers a rich, hands-on experience.
3.
Nat Sherman Townhouse (Midtown / near 42nd Street)
The Nat Sherman Townhouse is a storied boutique with deep roots in New York's cigar legacy. Though the company has seen corporate changes, the boutique retains a sophisticated selection of both classic and rare cigars, along with accessories and a refined shopping environment. Collectors often visit to access limited releases and special editions tied to the Nat Sherman brand.
4.
La Casa Grande Cigars (Bronx, Arthur Avenue)
La Casa Grande Cigars (LCG) is located down in the Bronx, on Arthur Avenue, where it's part of a rich tobacco and food culture. They roll by artisan techniques in their store, selling both standard and exclusive blends, and are well regarded for maintaining quality control and freshness. For collectors willing to venture out of Manhattan, LCG offers authenticity, lesser-known blends, and deep local flavor.
5.
Cigar Inn (Upper East Side / Midtown East)
Cigar Inn is more than a shop — it's a comfortable lounge environment that appeals to regular smokers and serious collectors alike. They maintain a well-stocked humidor, carry high-end boutique lines, and provide a relaxed space where you can sample, compare, and discuss cigars. Though not always the rarest of rare, its blend of selection, accessibility, and ambience make it a favorite stop for those exploring cigar culture in the heart of the city.
